Well, maybe, in the review that ends with the guy saying "I consider this my art", saying something like "It's weird you did it this way" is kind of scathing, from my viewpoint.
Since I brought up old comment arguments in the text of the review, here's another one; was told professionals don't cuss and rant in the comments, and obviously this commenter I was arguing with has never read professional reviews and their comments, because, oh my God, all the time. Just all the time. Because people are just assholes to critics. "Oh, you're a critic, so you must be able to take criticism; oh, wait, THAT MEANS I HAVE IMPUNITY TO BE AN ASSHOLE. FUCK, YEAH!"
Look, honestly, you liked the movie; I copped to being unfair to Sing multiple times in the review, in case you haven't noticed. I was late and had time to really dig into it, and I took it to task for essentially not being an anti-Trump screed, which is so fucking unfair it's not even funny.
Comparing it to Zootopia was pretty fair, though. I'm not going to budge from that. In fact, I use Sing to make fun of a scene in Zootopia; it's just as unfair to Zootopia (but you aren't whining about that, are you). Besides, it didn't really matter; it wouldn't have been a favorable review anyway. Sing compared to nothing, in my opinion, still sucked. It just never really popped; just too safe. The only risky bit it had, I noted, and gave it an admirable mention.
Also, please note the word "sucked" there now; accusing me of being as shitty reviewer really making like it a lot more now.
Well, maybe, in the review that ends with the guy saying "I consider this my art", saying something like "It's weird you did it this way" is kind of scathing, from my viewpoint.
Since I brought up old comment arguments in the text of the review, here's another one; was told professionals don't cuss and rant in the comments, and obviously this commenter I was arguing with has never read professional reviews and their comments, because, oh my God, all the time. Just all the time. Because people are just assholes to critics. "Oh, you're a critic, so you must be able to take criticism; oh, wait, THAT MEANS I HAVE IMPUNITY TO BE AN ASSHOLE. FUCK, YEAH!"
Look, honestly, you liked the movie; I copped to being unfair to Sing multiple times in the review, in case you haven't noticed. I was late and had time to really dig into it, and I took it to task for essentially not being an anti-Trump screed, which is so fucking unfair it's not even funny.
Comparing it to Zootopia was pretty fair, though. I'm not going to budge from that. In fact, I use Sing to make fun of a scene in Zootopia; it's just as unfair to Zootopia (but you aren't whining about that, are you). Besides, it didn't really matter; it wouldn't have been a favorable review anyway. Sing compared to nothing, in my opinion, still sucked. It just never really popped; just too safe. The only risky bit it had, I noted, and gave it an admirable mention.
Also, please note the word "sucked" there now; accusing me of being as shitty reviewer really making like it a lot more now.